December 9, 2023


Carefully Crafted Home

Got a Granny? Create Her a Dwelling in Your Backyard


The US has been trying to tackle the concern of housing affordability for decades with no a great deal to clearly show for it. And it is correct to be skeptical about the efficiency of coverage variations until eventually effects are obvious in the figures. For instance, the state of California, which arguably has the most acute housing affordability concerns in the US, has seen  no development in the range of making permits issued  in the state since the mid-2010s, and a substantial-profile law intended to make it easier to build duplexes has  so far not borne much fruit .

Granny flats, also known as backyard cottages or — in the lingo of city planners, accessory dwelling units (ADUs) — have set up a improved observe file. Housing activists and reformers have evidence that they’ve accomplished something significant with these ADUs, and years of development in both equally Los Angeles and Seattle can be replicated all around the state. If the intention is “build a lot more housing now,” ADUs may possibly be the very best place to target more than the following several yrs.

The biggest charm of ADUs is that they’re a complementary type of housing that avoids some of the “neighborhood character” objections that appear into play when builders suggest better-intensity assignments like condominium structures or superior-rises. In point, they typically provide as remedies for the types of people that are inclined to oppose the design of much more housing. But the pros of ADUs are a lot of: They let older inhabitants to age in place they produce alternatives for multi-generational dwelling and they can provide a resource of revenue for retired home owners who really do not want to shift but have more house on their house.

Encouragingly, there is evidence that the place communities have concentrated the most on removing barriers to creating ADUs, the variety of these new housing models is expanding — even if it took a couple of years to actually kick in. California passed a regulation in 2017 that encouraged ADU design and by 2021, more than 20% of making permit applications in the point out had been for ADUs. Seattle passed legislation addressing ADUs and over the past three a long time, ADU production in the city has elevated from 279 models in 2019 to practically 1,000 in 2022.

Development in some spots serves as inspiration for other folks that are having difficulties with housing affordability — and that’s virtually everywhere you go these times. I serve on the Setting up Commission in Brookhaven, Ga, exactly where I stay, and as element of a zoning rewrite in 2018 the city made a decision to make ADUs a part of our housing affordability system. Unlike LA and Seattle, nevertheless, we have still to see them acquire traction in our neighborhood, which has led us to try to recognize why.

Heading via that process can make you enjoy how several hurdles can exist when you’re starting off from zero —developers won’t want to construct ADUs except if there is community need for them, but group desire does not automatically exist till there is an recognition that ADUs are even an possibility — or that they’re an desirable possibility relative to alternate options. With less in-human being conferences for the duration of the past 3 years on top rated of housing offer chain issues, it also has been much more hard to coordinate on new insurance policies.

Eventually, all these problems have remedies. It is just about figuring out what the discomfort details are and addressing them, no matter whether it means tweaking the zoning code, streamlining the allowing course of action, conducting neighborhood outreach or other steps.

There is a cause I’m producing this column now rather of two years back. I’m optimistic that 2023 will be the very best calendar year still for ADU awareness and advancement. We now have municipal achievement tales to lead the way. For the initially time given that the onset of the pandemic the housing offer chain is loosening up, liberating methods for ADUs that in excess of the previous two a long time ended up absorbed by the increase in solitary-loved ones housing building.

And in an surroundings with increased property finance loan costs than we’re applied to, the granny flat provides a way to create housing that does not involve a big regular home loan payment. I spoke with a regional developer who will make a 2-bed room ADU for close to $250,000, or a 1-bed room for $200,000.

These tiny homes can functionally add far more housing provide than the one or two bedrooms that they have. A downsizing retiree may possibly be swapping out a primarily-vacant 4- or 5-bed room house in order to are living in an ADU upcoming to an adult little one, for occasion, liberating up that bigger residence for the young house.

Time will tell if extra ambitious housing reform proposals guide to the substantive alter that activists seek, but in the meantime there is momentum powering ADUs and we can make the most of these chances correct now.

Much more From Other Writers at Bloomberg Viewpoint:

• Conserve for a Residence or Retirement? Decide on the Latter: Erin Lowry

• That Instagram Aspiration Household Will Have to Hold out: Leticia Miranda

• Want to Treatment the Housing Crisis? Kill Zoning: Virginia Postrel

This column does not necessarily replicate the impression of the editorial board or Bloomberg LP and its proprietors.

Conor Sen is a Bloomberg Viewpoint columnist. He is founder of Peachtree Creek Investments.

Extra stories like this are accessible on